Kane Brown teamed with finalist Spensha Baker to sing his 2017 No. 1 hit, “What Ifs,” during the Season 14 finale of The Voice on May 22.

While the Team Blake Shelton member ended up finishing fourth, she performed a rousing rendition of the song in place of Lauren Alaina, who was featured on the album cut. The tune, which was penned by Kane, Matthew McGinn and Jordan Schmidt, was the third single from Kane’s 2016 self-titled debut album.

After a record 34 weeks atop Billboard’s Hot Country Songs chart, Sam Hunt’s “Body Like a Back Road” was dethroned by Kane’s “What Ifs” in October 2017.

Watch Kane and Spensha perform “What Ifs” below.